Homemade Yogurt

by Josée

I finally did it! After two months I managed to get myself organized enough to make yogurt. My biggest excuse for waiting this long was the ongoing debate inside my head over whether to buy a yogurt maker. So many websites and books claim that you can make yogurt without one. I was skeptical. How do you maintain a steady temperature of 110 degree F to incubating the yogurt with no yogurt maker? Answer: a digital thermometer!

Alright, so how did I make the yogurt?

Step 1: Read a book or two or websites or blog on yogurt making
I also used the book The Home Creamery by Kathy Farrell-Kingsley to get me started.

Step 2: Assemble equipment
a large heavy bottom pot
a ladle
a wooden spoon
sterilized glass jars and lids (place them in boiling water for 15 minutes)
a picnic cooler
a few old towels
a digital thermometer
a few glass jars filled with hot (52 degrees C) water

Sterilizing jars

Step 3: Assemble ingredients
4 cups of milk (whole milk works best)
yogurt starter: 1/4 cup plain yogurt or freeze dried yogurt starter (I used freeze dried starter from our health food store)

Step 4: Make yogurt
1. Heat milk to 85 degrees C (185 F) in large heavy bottom pot.
2. Remove from heat and let cool to 40-46 degrees C (105-115 F). You can cool milk more quickly over an ice bath to prevent unwanted bacteria from growing in milk.
3. Pour some milk into a small bowl and add yogurt starter. Mix well and then add back into pot of milk.
4. Pour milk into sterilized jars and cover with sterilized lids.

Step 5: Incubate in cooler
1. Line cooler with an old towel.
2. Place three large jars on bottom and fill with hot (52 degree C) water.
3. Place yogurt jars on bottom.
4. Put the probe end of the digital thermometer near yogurt jars.
5. Cover with an old towel and close lid. Monitor temperature and adjust accordingly (I never had to).
6. Incubate yogurt for 4-6 hours, depending on how firm and tart you like your yogurt.

Step 6: Refrigerate yogurt
The yogurt will keep in fridge for 2-3 weeks.

Step 7: Eat yogurt!

Related Articles


Tanya May 26, 2010 - 3:43 pm

WOW! That looks awesome!!!!!!!
I am so excited to try!!!!
Are you going to try flavoring it? That is my biggest intrest!

Josee May 26, 2010 - 4:57 pm

I'm going to try flavoring it next time (as per Hubby's request). I'll make sure to post my yogurt flavoring attempts 🙂

thefirstfouryears May 27, 2010 - 12:51 am

My husband refuses to eat yogurt…he thinks the process of making it is too gross. I think he has images of huge vats of green bacteria in his head…haha. Maybe this will change his mind?

I love yogurt and that looks totally scrumptious. Do let us know how your flavoring attempts go.

Josee May 27, 2010 - 1:43 am

Lol, yogurt is a far cry from blue cheese 🙂

cindyswobblog May 27, 2010 - 4:53 am

Josee, you did it! I was skeptical, but I shouldn't have doubted you:) I'm so impressed that you made your own yogurt – how long did the entire process take and was it easy enough that you would do it again? Did you like the taste? Did it taste just like regular yogurt? I can't wait to hear about your next project – they're always so exciting! Take care


Leave a Comment